Landis is now bringing award-winning design-build expertise to Annapolis

Lor

Design-Build vs. Architect Plus General Contractor: The Real Cost and Risk Comparison

Design-build or architect plus general contractor? Compare cost, schedule and risk for a DC-area renovation, and see why one team often works best.

If you're planning a major renovation or addition in the DC area, one of the first decisions you'll make is how the project gets delivered. You can hire an architect to design it and then bid it out to a general contractor. Or you can hire a design-build firm that handles both under one roof.

On paper, the two paths can look similar. In practice, they lead to very different experiences with cost, schedule and risk. As a design-build firm that's been working in the DC area since 1990, we have a point of view. Here's an honest look at how the two compare, and where each one makes sense.

Design-build vs. design-bid-build: how each model works 

Architect plus general contractor (design-bid-build)

In the traditional model, you sign two separate contracts:

  1. You hire an architect, who designs the project and produces construction drawings.
  2. The drawings go out to bid, and contractors price the finished design.
  3. You choose a contractor and sign a second contract to build it.
  4. The architect may stay involved during construction, depending on what services you've paid for.

The architect and the contractor each work for you, but not for each other. Under standard AIA contracts, the architect isn't even a party to your agreement with the builder.

Design-build

With design-build, one firm is responsible for both design and construction under a single contract. At Landis, that covers architecture, interior design, permitting, project management and construction. In practice, our process moves from schematic design to design development, construction documents, pre-construction and construction, with the same team carrying the project from first sketch to final walkthrough.

Cost: knowing the number while you design

The biggest cost difference between the two models comes down to timing: when you find out what your project will actually cost.

In design-bid-build, the real price usually arrives after the drawings are done and contractors submit bids. If those bids come in over budget, you're left with hard choices: cut scope, swap finishes or go back to the architect for a redesign. Redesign means more design fees and more months before construction starts.

Design-build flips that order. Because the people pricing the work are part of the design team, cost and buildability are discussed from the first meeting. At Landis, schematic design includes detailed as-built drawings, 3D models and a construction budget estimate, so you can see how design decisions affect cost before you commit to them. Instead of designing something beautiful and then finding out it's unaffordable, you get to the best design for your budget faster.

Our builders also review the design as it develops, so details that would be hard or expensive to build get solved on paper, not in the field. That means fewer change orders during construction.

Research points the same way. A 2018 study by the Construction Industry Institute and the Charles Pankow Foundation of 212 projects estimated that design-build projects had about 3.8% less cost growth than design-bid-build. Those were mostly larger commercial and public buildings, not single-family homes, but the reason is the same: when design and construction share one team, there are fewer gaps for cost to grow into.

Design: your home, not a signature style

Many architecture firms are known for a signature look. That can be wonderful if it's exactly what you want. But it also means the design often starts from the architect's style rather than from your home and the way you live in it.

We take the opposite approach. Landis designs to the client and the house. A Capitol Hill rowhouse, a Chevy Chase colonial and a modern addition in McLean each call for something different, and our job is to find the right answer for that home and that family. You can see the range in our portfolio, from historic renovations that respect a home's original character to fully reimagined whole-home remodels.

Design doesn't take a back seat, either. As our post on whether design-build is right for you points out, the model only works if a firm has strong design and construction departments. Our in-house architects and designers work side by side with the people who build what they draw.

Schedule: waiting for a spot on the calendar

In the traditional model, a contractor usually isn't on board until the design is well along or finished and bid. Good contractors in the DC area are busy, so once you pick one, you often have to wait for an opening in their schedule. That gap can add months between finishing your drawings and breaking ground.

The bidding process takes time too, and if the numbers come in high, a redesign adds another round.

In design-build, your construction team is part of the project from day one. Pre-construction planning, permitting and scheduling happen alongside design, so construction can start soon after the drawings are done. The same study found design-build projects were delivered 102% faster overall than design-bid-build. A big reason is that design and construction planning can overlap instead of happening one after the other. For more on timing, see how long a remodeling project typically takes.

Risk: who's responsible when something falls through the cracks?

This is the most common complaint we hear from homeowners who have been through the traditional model: they ended up playing general contractor themselves.

It usually starts small. A detail isn't fully drawn, or a site condition doesn't match the plans. The contractor says it's a design issue. The architect says it's a construction issue. Each points to their contract, and neither is technically wrong. The homeowner, who is the only person with a contract with both, is left to sort it out, make the decision and often pay for the fix.

That's not a knock on architects or contractors. It's how the model is built: two separate contracts leave natural gaps, and the homeowner sits in the middle.

Design-build closes those gaps with a single point of responsibility. One firm owns the design and the construction, so when a question comes up, there's no one else to point to. The Design-Build Institute of America notes that design-build results in fewer changes, fewer claims and less litigation. At Landis, the same team stays with your project from design through construction and our two-year warranty.

Interior design and permits: more handoffs, more risk

The gaps in the traditional model often go beyond the architect and the contractor.

Interior design. Some architects don’t offer interior design, so you end up hiring an interior designer too. Now there are three firms to coordinate, three sets of fees and more chances for miscommunication. A tile layout that doesn’t line up with the plumbing, or a lighting plan that doesn’t match the cabinetry, can mean rework, added cost and delays. At Landis, interior design is part of the same team. We handle all the hard finishes, like tile, cabinetry, countertops, plumbing fixtures and lighting, so they’re designed alongside the architecture from the start.

Furnishings and landscape design. When a renovation calls for a more holistic approach, Landis can also provide interior furnishing services, like sofas, rugs and other soft furnishings, along with landscape design. These aren't included in our standard design-build process, but they can easily be added as hourly design services. Having that expertise in-house and involved from the outset means the furniture plan, the outdoor spaces and the architecture all work together, instead of being pieced together by different firms after the fact.

Permitting. In design-bid-build, who pulls the permit can vary. Sometimes it's the architect, sometimes the contractor, sometimes a permit expediter, and sometimes the homeowner. When responsibility isn't clear, the wrong permit can get pulled or the scope on the permit may not match the work. That leads to failed inspections, revisions and delays. In design-build, permitting is one firm's job. Our pre-construction team prepares and manages the permit as part of the process, so it matches the drawings and the work we're actually going to build.

When an architect plus GC can make sense

Design-build isn't the only good path. The traditional model can be a good fit if:

  • You already have an architect you love, or you want a specific architect's signature style.
  • You want to bid a finished set of drawings to several contractors.
  • You're prepared to stay closely involved and manage the relationship between the two firms.

If you go this route, protect yourself. Pay for construction administration services from your architect, get a cost estimate during design rather than waiting for bids, and bring a contractor in early if you can.

For most homeowners planning a major renovation, though, the questions that matter most are simple. What will it cost, when will it be done, and who is responsible? Design-build gives clearer answers to all three.

Design-build vs. architect plus GC at a glance

Design-build vs. architect plus GC at a glance
Architect plus GC Design-build
Contracts Two, or three with a separate interior designer One
When you learn the real cost After drawings are finished and bid Estimated during schematic design and refined as you go
Buildability review Usually after design is complete Built into the design process
Design approach Often shaped by the architect's style Shaped by your home and how you live
Interior design Sometimes a separate firm Included, with all hard finishes
Permitting Varies by project and can fall through the cracks Handled by the design-build firm
Contractor availability Starts when the contractor's schedule opens up Planned alongside design
Who resolves gaps Often the homeowner The design-build firm
Best for Homeowners who want a specific architect and are ready to manage multiple firms Homeowners who want one accountable team and clear answers on cost and schedule

Choosing the right path for your renovation

Both models can produce a beautiful home. The difference is how you get there, and who carries the risk along the way.

If you're weighing your options for a renovation or addition in DC, Maryland or Northern Virginia, we'd be glad to walk you through our process and what it would look like for your home. Read our 7 tips for choosing the right design partner, or contact us to start the conversation.

Design-build vs. design-bid-build: FAQ

Is design-build more expensive than hiring an architect and a contractor?

Not necessarily. Design-build tends to reduce the costs that add up later, like redesign after over-budget bids and change orders during construction. Research on larger commercial and public projects points to less cost growth with design-build.

How much does design cost with a design-build firm?

At Landis, design services are billed hourly and typically total 10% to 12% of the project's estimated construction cost.

Is design-build faster?

Generally, yes. Construction planning and scheduling happen during design, so you don't wait for bids or for a contractor's calendar to open up after the drawings are done.

Do I lose design quality with design-build?

Not with the right firm. Look for a design-build company with licensed architects and a strong in-house design team, not just a builder that outsources drawings.

Can I still get competitive pricing with design-build?

Yes. A good design-build firm prices the project openly as the design develops and competitively bids subcontracted trades, so you see where your money goes throughout.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Prefer to talk to one of our team members first?
(202) 726-3777
CALL NOW